Leatherique Before/After + Warning for use on perforated "Y" section of seat leather
I recently used the lauded Leatherique system (Rejuvenator Oil + Prestine Clean) with adverse and seemingly irreversible effects on the perforated leather which forms the "Y" section of each seat. I used the product on a '91-93 type car, which I believe has leather of a different and perhaps thicker kind than later cars.
Specifically, while the unperforated leather improved, the perforated leather shrunk, hardened, developed bizarre textural changes similar to scars and nodules, and lost some colour despite not being re-dyed (Leatherique advise that their product will remove after-market dye).
It was also impossible to keep the perforated areas clean for more than a few days, as they seep Rejuvenator Oil despite repeated cleaning with Prestine Clean, particularly in hot weather (heat increases expulsion). Several months later the seats still require cleaning every few days to prevent staining clothing.
I contacted the local (Australian) distributor and they advised I continue reapplications until I restore the leather by continuing to remove impurities (I sent them a large batch of progress photos) and to drive the product in with extra heat. The tacky/hazy finish they describe is supposed to be impurities floating to the surface for removal by step 2 (Prestine Clean).
Unfortunately reapplication made things worse, there was additional colour extracted, additional shrinkage and no improvement, either short-term or weeks later in the other surprise changes. I also contacted the US manufacturer a few weeks ago and did not receive a reply.
The seats weren't that dirty and only lightly used, so I suspect the tacky finish is due to the Leatherique having questionable suitability in this case. Either the perforated leather is not holding on to the "correct nutrients" the product contains, or it is too perforated to allow it to ever finish without substantial ongoing release the product.
None of the issues apply to the other leather types used (upper backrest, bolsters, front of squab).
I would recommend applying Leatherique very sparingly to the perforated "Y" section (if at all), and waiting at least 3 weeks to assess the outcome before a reapplication, as the final result materializes several weeks after the process is complete.
As for the "scars" and "nodules", hardening, and the colour leak, I think only repeated cleaning over time and the physical pressure of sitting which may resolve them... At this rate it's going to be an indefinite period of time.