Making a good choice in today's tire world goes WAAaaay beyond simply choosing your favorite brand.
First you must determine what is most important to you. Is it long tire life? Is it maximum hard driving traction? Do you need snow traction? Do you want maximum highway smoothness?
If you want long tire life, look at the UTQG number on the tire. The higher the number, the longer tread life. The high UTQG numbers are found on 75 series tires. The highest number will usually compromise maximum traction. If you drive normally most any tire will give enough traction, so go for the high UTQG number. If you drive in snow alot, go for an all season tire with a high number.
If you live in a high temperature area and want long tire life, make sure the tire has a temp rating of A.
Once you select the tire, make SURE that you get a dynamic balance. This means weights on the inside AND outside of the wheel. Without them, you will be guaranteed to have vibration at highway speed on a 123 car.
Hope this helps.