Mercedes-Benz Forum banner
1 - 9 of 9 Posts

· Registered
2001 E-430
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I have a 2001 MB E-430 with 165K miles on the OD. I began experiencing a problem with the transmission after having an oil change. I had a trusted and experienced shop do a Mobil 1 oil change (rec synthetic European car formula) with the rec Mobil 1 filter. I have never had any problem with transmission in the past. Could the oil change have effected the transmission?

The auto transmission is slipping and seeminly is not progessing through the gears. The RPM are higher than they should be and it feels like the car is stuck in a lower gear. Again, I have never had a problem the feel is having a problem.

Any suggestions?

JT in GA
 

· Registered
'01-E320 & 02-ST2
Joined
·
31,798 Posts
Yes.

Have it drained and flushed with spec fluid. Mobil1 ATF does not meet MB spec for your transmission, which is 236.10.

There is a wealth of information about your car in the W210 forum, including tons of info about your transmission and the proper fluid.

Good luck.
 

· Outstanding Contributor - Always Remembered, RIP
Zotye Auto 1.5T T600 2016
Joined
·
52,890 Posts
I have a 2001 MB E-430 with 165K miles on the OD. I began experiencing a problem with the transmission after having an oil change. I had a trusted and experienced shop do a Mobil 1 oil change (rec synthetic European car formula) with the rec Mobil 1 filter. I have never had any problem with transmission in the past. Could the oil change have effected the transmission?

The auto transmission is slipping and seeminly is not progessing through the gears. The RPM are higher than they should be and it feels like the car is stuck in a lower gear. Again, I have never had a problem the feel is having a problem.

Any suggestions?

JT in GA
Was it the engine oil they changed or the transmission fluid? Mobil 1 is for engines.
 

· Registered
2001 E-430
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Was it the engine oil they changed or the transmission fluid? Mobil 1 is for engines.
POINT OF CLARIFICATION. It was the engine oil not the ATF that was changed. Again after changing engine oil with Mobile 1 synthetic and Mobil 1 filter, I began experiencing transmission problems. My E-430 sedan has 165,000 miles and before the oil change I had never had the first problem with the transmission. Not one. The transmission has never been serviced. I have never added or changed the ATF. There is not even a dipstick to check it. It was my understanding that it was sealed at the factory and did not require regular maintenance. I know that the engine oil and the ATF are separate. However, is it possible that when the engine oil was changed that the technician either spilled some of the Mobile 1 or a leak of the Mobile 1 somehow caused a problem with the transmission. My thought is that the electronics could have been inadvertently compromised during the oil change. That is just a guess. I am still trying to figure why the problem happened and if it could be related to the work. More importantly, I need advice on how to diagnose the transmission problem and get it fixed as quickly and inexpensively as possible. Any suggestions. BTW, I did read the posted PDF on the 210 transmission in the sedan forum. A little to technical for me. I'll share it with the shop today as I am on my way to have them pull the codes and put it on the rack. All the best, JT in GA
 

· Outstanding Contributor - Always Remembered, RIP
Zotye Auto 1.5T T600 2016
Joined
·
52,890 Posts
Thank you for the clarification but the engine oil change should not affect the transmission in any way, better to wait for the codes.
 

· Registered
2001 E-430
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Transmission problem: Got Codes

Thank you for the clarification but the engine oil change should not affect the transmission in any way, better to wait for the codes.
Just back from the shop (Theo's in Peachtree City, GA). He pulled codes
on my E-430 and here is what we have:
P2502 and P220A. I plan to get the car back to the shop on Monday after
a little due diligence on my part.

I assume I may need to plan a transmission service at the same time. Again, the vehicle has 165,000 miles and has never had the transmission serviced.
I plan to use whatever the rec is for ATF.

But first things first. Need to understand what the codes are telling me. I believe the trnsmsission PDF on the 210 sedan blog may have some useful info. The trouble is that it is somewhat too technical for me. I also, did a search in the 210 sedan for transmission and got some useful info. Especially the pictures posted. Again a little technical as I am not a card carrying DIY like many of you guys.

JT in GA
 

· Outstanding Contributor - Always Remembered, RIP
Zotye Auto 1.5T T600 2016
Joined
·
52,890 Posts

· Registered
'01-E320 & 02-ST2
Joined
·
31,798 Posts
Just back from the shop (Theo's in Peachtree City, GA). He pulled codes
on my E-430 and here is what we have:
P2502 and P220A. I plan to get the car back to the shop on Monday after
a little due diligence on my part.

I assume I may need to plan a transmission service at the same time. Again, the vehicle has 165,000 miles and has never had the transmission serviced.
I plan to use whatever the rec is for ATF.

But first things first. Need to understand what the codes are telling me. I believe the trnsmsission PDF on the 210 sedan blog may have some useful info. The trouble is that it is somewhat too technical for me. I also, did a search in the 210 sedan for transmission and got some useful info. Especially the pictures posted. Again a little technical as I am not a card carrying DIY like many of you guys.

JT in GA
Ah, since Mobil1 does make a synthetic AT fluid you added facts that did nothing but confuse. ;)

If you've ignored your transmission by buying into the "maintenance free" marketing nonsense, you've been lucky.

Based on the codes you may or may not be (lucky). Since you say you're not technical and relying on others, then take it in for service and have them do the things listed below. DO NOT go to the dealer, they no longer have the spec fluid for your car, and you will only add to your woes. Find an MB-specializing indy or an indy transmission shop that specializes in German cars.

1. Check the TCM to see if it has fluid incursion. If so, remove and clean with electronic parts cleaner, and disconnect the harness at the transmission and spray cleaner down the harness to flush out the excess fluid. When dry reinstall TCM.

2. Remove pan and clean. Replace pilot bushing/adapter/spacer (where harness plugged in) with redesigned part, being sure to source the part from the dealer, not the aftermarket. Plug the harness back in.

3. Fit new filter and reinstall pan. Fill with 236.10 spec fluid only.

4. Using proper equipment (snap-on, SDS, Carsoft) clear transmission codes.

5. Start car and set proper fluid levels at 25c and 80c.

6. Repeat fluid and filter service in 20,000 miles (the above service will only change about a third, and at that mileage I'd be hesitant to change all of it at once).


That's the most inexpensive way to proceed. If that doesn't do it, then it's likely you have internal issues with the transmission, perhaps a conductor plate, perhaps more. But at that mileage and having waited that long to do a simple fluid change, it may be more expedient to just replace the transmission with a rebuilt unit, since it's life has already been shortened by being ignored for so long.

And no, an oil change can't affect the transmission unless someone was a complete idiot and drained the transmission instead of the engine, in which case the car wouldn't have moved afterward to begin with and the engine would have been so overfilled with oil that it likely wouldn't run. (And yes, I've known of such stupid things happening.) But if it's a "trusted and experienced" shop they wouldn't do that.

Good luck.

PS: May I also suggest that in the future when you have a specific issue with your car that you actually post in the 210 forum (what I'm guessing you're referring to as the "sedan forum")? This introduction forum is just that, a place to say hi, here I am, and really not to enter technical discussions about your car. Specific info on specific models -- that's what the sub-forums are all about. :thumbsup:
 

· Registered
2001 E-430
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Thanks for link and follow-up question

Thank you. I'll suggest that course of action to the mechanic (Theo's Automotive of Peachtree City, GA: THEO'S AUTOMOTIVE Home Page). by the
way, I am dealing directly with Theo.

3 Questions regarding diagnosing/repairing my 2001 E-430 transmission issue:

1) What is the correct name of what I have variously seen referred to as the "transmission control unit" by one blogger and the "electronic control module" by others?
2) How much shuld I expect to pay (be charged) for the unit + ancillary parts and installation at Theo's
3) Regarding transmission flush. What is spec ATF and spec filter for the 2001E-430. I am willing to purchase parts/supplies and have shop do the work. It is very important to me to always use what the spec or rec is.

JT in GA
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top