Mercedes-Benz Forum banner

Photo DIY- Engine Oil Change via the "Sucky" Method

58258 Views 59 Replies 26 Participants Last post by  FireFox31
10
Greets.

I know I am going to lambasted for my "extremist", anal-compulsive approach to vehicle maintenance... To be PERFECTLY CLEAR, I am NOT in any way promoting "Break-In" Oil changes. I guess "old-school" ways are hard to break (ie. the days of 600 mile oil change).

Well, after the 1.500 km "break-in" period (which I also do to excess, keeping under 2.000 rpm)
I went ahead with an oil change. Please don't cast stones, or send the "Green" Geo-Nazi's to my door for wasting said oil... to me it is cheap insurance.. just like when I do 5.000 mile oil changes, even with synthetic.

This basic post is designed to show those who may be too timid to do their own oil changes, "It's no big deal, and easy to do!" I feel there is a certain "bond" between owner and car when maintenance is done.

I will probably also open up the can of worms by recommending the "Sucky" vacuum method of oil removal. I've tried BOTH drain and suck methods, and EACH time I got nearly 200 cc of EXTRA OIL via the Sucky method vs. drain... Plus?? the sucky method, you can do in your White Tuxedo, and not get a drop on you.... try that with the "drain" method! Also, no jacking safety issues to contend with.

A few notes:

This is for a M272 engine on E350.

The Oil Listed, Mobil 1 Formula M 5W-40... this is **NOT THE SAME AS** Mobil 1 "ESP" Formula M 5w-40. Originally, the "ESP" version was BRIEFLY included on sheet 229.5 (Gasoline Engines), but was later pulled by MB. The "ESP" is on sheet 229.51 and is for Diesel Engines...
The Mobil 1 Formula M is ONLY available through the MB Dealerships... Trust me, I even tried BRIBING Mobil Oil, and several Distributors to sell to me directly, to no avail... Don't worry, though, it is actually cheaper than you think.. I got mine for $6.02 per quart from MB, which is quite a bit less than the Brand X auto parts store which is probably closer to $8 bucks.


You will see the two variations of oil filters. In the past, with the same part number
000 180 26 09 MB box would sometimes be a Mahle, and sometimes Mann. Nowadays, it seems to be solely Mann (with the FLAT edge in the photo below). Some Guru MB mechanics believe the Mahle-type provides a slightly better "seal" due to its extra "Lip" on the ends. I'm sure I'll catch flak for that, but my "proof-in-the-pudding" is my AMG engine on the G came with the Mahle-type installed... "If it's good enough for AMG, it's good enough for me too"..
You can get the Mahle type from AutohausAZ. The Mahle number is OX 345 D.

One note on the Mann-Type... there is a "Line" on the filter element that you need to TWIST the filter onto the holder COMPLETELY, so that the "line" on the filter lines up with the holder edge.


Once the oil is in, and you take it for a drive to check for leaks, and to warm the new oil, you must check the oil level on a flat floor, and wait FIVE MINUTES after shutting off the engine... Wipe off the dipstick, re-insert and hold inserted for AT LEAST 3 seconds to obtain a correct reading..

Anyhooo, enough babbling...enjoy!

Attachments

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
1 - 20 of 60 Posts
3
part II

partII

Attachments

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
My 98 E was the same. Things don t change much but I used the sucky method in 1998 and will do the same when my 2010 needs an oil change. My only question is with the SPECIAL oil. I thought in the USA that manufactures could nt do the "only our oil" thing.
Whats so special about their M mobil oil? Thanks for taking time to post that "How To" with pics.I m sure it will help.
My 98 E was the same. Things don t change much but I used the sucky method in 1998 and will do the same when my 2010 needs an oil change. My only question is with the SPECIAL oil. I thought in the USA that manufactures could nt do the "only our oil" thing.
Whats so special about their M mobil oil? Thanks for taking time to post that "How To" with pics.I m sure it will help.

My understanding of the USA rules is, that a car company can not REQUIRE you to use their proprietary product... Look at Sheet 229.5, there are a zillion oils to choose from, you don't HAVE to solely use Formula M.

Now, there is nothing wrong with an OEM supplier to MB who will only sell a product under the MB name, or use a MB dealership as a sole outlet for purchase.

The reason I used this particular oil?? To be honest, in the past, I have followed one half of the MB "Schizophrenic" approach to oil recommendations. Don't you find it strange, that the owner's manual gives you a chart with what viscosity to use for various climates, yet on the service sheets, they "force" you into only a few viscosities??

Since I live in the 7th ring of Dante's Inferno, it gets so bloody hot, that I have always been leery of putting 0W-40 into my cars. On the W210, W140, and the W460 , from day one ex-Sindelfingen, have used 20W-50 (a weight indicated in the owner's manual) Mobil 1, and have had ZERO engine issues, and the G is over, and the S close to 250.000 km. Now, the W463 is another story.... apparently AMG is very strict about using ONLY an "X"W-40 in the M113 engine, so this is where I learned of the 5W-40 Formula M Mobil 1. If you notice, there are NO approved 10W-40 oils on the Sheet 229.5.

So, this is the method to my madness....

G
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Appreciate the informative and excellent write-up.
For Mobil 1 look for the gasoline Manufacturers ILSAC GF-4 (starburst), you should be good to go.
Thanks for the write up.

I just went to the dealer to buy this oil and was comparing the labels to a Mobil 1 0W40 that I use for my other cars.
The 5W40 label specifies only Mercedes on it and no other cars. It's almost as if it was made just for Mercedes. I wonder if they cut a deal so that this oil is only available at the dealer and no where else to control pricing and discourage the DIYer from doing the oil change.

Pricing was all over the place too. One dealer quoted me $10.25 per quart.

Would it be ok to just use the Mobil 1 0W40 that was previously approved for all MB vehicles in a new 2010 E350?
Thanks for the write up.

I just went to the dealer to buy this oil and was comparing the labels to a Mobil 1 0W40 that I use for my other cars.
The 5W40 label specifies only Mercedes on it and no other cars. It's almost as if it was made just for Mercedes. I wonder if they cut a deal so that this oil is only available at the dealer and no where else to control pricing and discourage the DIYer from doing the oil change.

Pricing was all over the place too. One dealer quoted me $10.25 per quart.

Would it be ok to just use the Mobil 1 0W40 that was previously approved for all MB vehicles in a new 2010 E350?
I will.
So, this is the method to my madness....

G
G-AMG. Great job in putting this together. Thank you!
:thumbsup:
Thanks for the write up.


The 5W40 label specifies only Mercedes on it and no other cars. It's almost as if it was made just for Mercedes.
Pricing was all over the place too. One dealer quoted me $10.25 per quart.

Would it be ok to just use the Mobil 1 0W40 that was previously approved for all MB vehicles in a new 2010 E350?
Yes, I believe it really is formulated just for MB.

$10.25/qt?? Whoooo. That's high. I paid $6.02/qt. Try one of the "Wholesale" MB dealerships like Duval on the East coast, or Caliber Motors West coast.

It's not a huge deal.... the Mobil 1 0W-40 is perfectly fine... I just have a personal preference for not using 0 weight oil....

G
G-AMG:
I have been looking everywhere for one of those SHURflo systems. Cant find them anywhere. Any hints?
Thanks!!!
Thanks! I was having "an out of body experience" and couldnt find it anywhere. Appreciate it.
Greets.

I know I am going to lambasted for my "extremist", anal-compulsive approach to vehicle maintenance... To be PERFECTLY CLEAR, I am NOT in any way promoting "Break-In" Oil changes. I guess "old-school" ways are hard to break (ie. the days of 600 mile oil change).

Well, after the 1.500 km "break-in" period (which I also do to excess, keeping under 2.000 rpm)
I went ahead with an oil change. Please don't cast stones, or send the "Green" Geo-Nazi's to my door for wasting said oil... to me it is cheap insurance.. just like when I do 5.000 mile oil changes, even with synthetic.

This basic post is designed to show those who may be too timid to do their own oil changes, "It's no big deal, and easy to do!" I feel there is a certain "bond" between owner and car when maintenance is done.

I will probably also open up the can of worms by recommending the "Sucky" vacuum method of oil removal. I've tried BOTH drain and suck methods, and EACH time I got nearly 200 cc of EXTRA OIL via the Sucky method vs. drain... Plus?? the sucky method, you can do in your White Tuxedo, and not get a drop on you.... try that with the "drain" method! Also, no jacking safety issues to contend with.

A few notes:

This is for a M272 engine on E350.

The Oil Listed, Mobil 1 Formula M 5W-40... this is **NOT THE SAME AS** Mobil 1 "ESP" Formula M 5w-40. Originally, the "ESP" version was BRIEFLY included on sheet 229.5 (Gasoline Engines), but was later pulled by MB. The "ESP" is on sheet 229.51 and is for Diesel Engines...
The Mobil 1 Formula M is ONLY available through the MB Dealerships... Trust me, I even tried BRIBING Mobil Oil, and several Distributors to sell to me directly, to no avail... Don't worry, though, it is actually cheaper than you think.. I got mine for $6.02 per quart from MB, which is quite a bit less than the Brand X auto parts store which is probably closer to $8 bucks.


You will see the two variations of oil filters. In the past, with the same part number
000 180 26 09 MB box would sometimes be a Mahle, and sometimes Mann. Nowadays, it seems to be solely Mann (with the FLAT edge in the photo below). Some Guru MB mechanics believe the Mahle-type provides a slightly better "seal" due to its extra "Lip" on the ends. I'm sure I'll catch flak for that, but my "proof-in-the-pudding" is my AMG engine on the G came with the Mahle-type installed... "If it's good enough for AMG, it's good enough for me too"..
You can get the Mahle type from AutohausAZ. The Mahle number is OX 345 D.

One note on the Mann-Type... there is a "Line" on the filter element that you need to TWIST the filter onto the holder COMPLETELY, so that the "line" on the filter lines up with the holder edge.


Once the oil is in, and you take it for a drive to check for leaks, and to warm the new oil, you must check the oil level on a flat floor, and wait FIVE MINUTES after shutting off the engine... Wipe off the dipstick, re-insert and hold inserted for AT LEAST 3 seconds to obtain a correct reading..

Anyhooo, enough babbling...enjoy!
Great job G AMG :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Recently i've changed oil on my W220. Funny thing was that i decided to make oil "sucky" by my self. I've got pipe to fit in oil dip stick and attached to a stiff plastic 25L can. Made a hole for vacuume cleaner to suck air. Whole project cost me less than 5 quid but it failed :crybaby2: because plastic can walls could not hold sucking pressure. At least i tried :D
. Whole project cost me less than 5 quid but it failed :crybaby2: because plastic can walls could not hold sucking pressure. At least i tried :D[/QUOTE


Oh well.. it you are only out 5 quid... no big loss.

Perhaps a METAL can?
We may want to be careful about this model on Amazon...dimensions don't match the specs of the model 4000:300. Just sent an e-mail to Shurflo customer service.

Jim
I used the ShurFlo 4000/300 last week. Worked like a charm. Perfect!
Hi - thanks. Wasn't sure that the model sold on Amazon was the 4000/300.
Jim
Improving SHURFlo Performance?

G-AMG - First, thanks for this thread. Well, my e-350 just hit 10K miles and I decided to change my oil yesterday. Everything went great except sucking out the oil.

Engine was warm and I put a piece of tape the length of the dipstick + 1 inch.
It started out fine, but slowed to a crawl. I only ended up extractring 7 qrs after 2 hours.

Any tips that aren't in the instructions? Would it help to shorten the tube a bit? There was always suction, and I played around with pushing/pulling in and out. Thoughts would be appreciated.:)

Thanks!
Jim
1 - 20 of 60 Posts
Top