dead giveaway you need a new tensioner is if you remove it from the engine and look at it,
the good one, on the right, a virtual line between the 'flats' on the shaft points at the pulley. the bad one on the left, they don't.

the good one, on the right, a virtual line between the 'flats' on the shaft points at the pulley. the bad one on the left, they don't.