There is lot of myths about oils. The viscosity is not parallel with mentioned shear strength.
Than in the case of motor oils, the low cold viscosity actually helps to protect the engine by starting the lubrication on cold start up much faster than the heavy oil, that keeps engine running with no oil pressure for long time.
If the lower viscosity oil is MB approved - I would use it unless I would live in Mojave, or similar location.
New oils, especially synthetics give much better protection, than the old oils even if you drop few points on viscosity level.
Than in the case of motor oils, the low cold viscosity actually helps to protect the engine by starting the lubrication on cold start up much faster than the heavy oil, that keeps engine running with no oil pressure for long time.
If the lower viscosity oil is MB approved - I would use it unless I would live in Mojave, or similar location.
New oils, especially synthetics give much better protection, than the old oils even if you drop few points on viscosity level.