ha. wow. This garbage truck mechanic really got himself worked up.
And yes, Napa is probably wrong. Here's some good articles for all to read. Heck, go ahead and google anti-seize lug and read the hundreds of arguments for or against. All those for anti-seize simply state "they've used it in the past and nothing bad ever happened" while those against seemed to break it down with much more intelligent arguments. See for yourself
taken from
Tundra Solutions Forum "I once worked with an engineer whose previous job was writing software for a "bolt tightening measuring whatsit" to be used by NASA. The intent was to measure the tension forces on a tightened bolt by measuring the lengthwise stretch of the bolt as it was tightened. The method was ultrasonic transducers, microprocessors, and software. It worked nicely.
What developed from their research was that the relationship between the torque applied to the bolt and the lengthwise tension forces induced thereby is highly dependent on the condition of the threads. For example, if the threads are dirty and/or rusted, it can require a high torque just to turn the bolt, much less tighten it. The problem with anti-sieze compound is that it lubricates the threads, which can result in a very much higher tension in the bolt than the torque used to tighten it would provide with clean, dry threads. So, if you put it on your lug bolts and tighten it to the recommended 83 ft-lbs of torque, you could break the stud, or the wheel, or both, or you could warp the brake drum, the hub, or the disk.
I understand the desire to use anti-sieze compound on lug bolts. I once broke a lug off while taking a lug not OFF because it siezed up. Since then, I've made sure I have clean, dry, rust-free threads before putting a lug nut on, and I've never had a problem since.""
Brake & Front End Blog: NO ANTI-SEIZE ON WHEEL STUDS OR LUG NUTS Tire Tech Information - How to Install Your Wheel & Tire Package What torque wrenches measure
Then again, I have "no f*ing clue what I'm talking about, eh?" This guy's like the next Governor Blagojevich