Mercedes-Benz Forum banner

Soft top closed switches?

25K views 16 replies 13 participants last post by  RESTO SL  
#1 ·
I just had the dealer run diagnostics because my soft top light was blinking when closed. The top opens and closes fine, it just blinks red when the top is closed. Anyways, the dealer said the "left and right soft top closed switches" need to be replaced for $1600. Does anyone know what parts he's referring to and if this is a DIY job in your opinion.

Thanks
Jeff

2000 500 SL
 
#7 ·
Adjusting "soft top closed switches"

I just had the dealer run diagnostics because my soft top light was blinking when closed. The top opens and closes fine, it just blinks red when the top is closed. Anyways, the dealer said the "left and right soft top closed switches" need to be replaced for $1600. Does anyone know what parts he's referring to and if this is a DIY job in your opinion.
Read this: http://www.benzworld.org/forums/r129-sl-class/1716168-fix-new-soft-top-new-front.html#post5819311 Klaus has lots of information on this forum, do a search, I'm sure you'll find what you're looking for at a lot less than $1600.
Jeff,

Those shops with Star Diagnosis would eventually point at the front locks - less experienced shops might even suggest to get a new controller. Almost any shop would tell you to replace the front locks, because they don't know about the ultimately simple adjustment procedure below.

Fritha78 was referring to a thread that was just posted yesterday. The OP's problem was that the rear of the soft top wouldn't even close after a new soft top canvas was installed, and the root cause was the same.

The red light staying on and the chime going off once you start driving is a less severe version of the problem, and the chime only going off once you drive over a bump would be the version where the switches just start needing adjustment.

It is unusual that both micro switches need adjustment at the same time. Has any work been done to the front locks lately, where someone might have bumped the switches out of alignment, or did you replace the canvas or the weatherstripping above the windshield?

In any case, below is the procedure to adjust the front lock micro switches, mostly paraphrased from the thread that Fritha78 referenced:

Here is how to check which one of the front lock micro switches needs adjustment in your case, where the red light stays on after the top has closed all the way:

Put the soft top tool (6-mm Allen wrench) into the front lock on one side, through the hole in front of the visor. Turn the wrench such that it locks even farther, taking the play out of the lock. That direction is different on the opposite sides, by the way. It is counter-clockwise on the left side and clockwise on the right side. If the red light goes out, then you have found the lock that needs adjustment.

Try the same on the other side if necessary.

(You might get away with only adjusting the prongs on your soft top, following the instructions in http://www.benzworld.org/forums/r129...djustment.html, but that would likely be only a temporary fix and eventually result in the chime going off every time you drive over a bump.)

Adjustment procedure:

Note that you need to re-install the windshield header panel before the top will operate on model years '95+. Also, be careful not to pull on the wires of the magnetic sensor that is mounted in the windshield header panel on model years '95+. See page 3 of http://www.tophydraulicsinc.com/R129... Removal.pdf.

The micro switch on the front lock(s) gets pushed DOWN by a lever when the lock is OPEN. There is some reverse logic involved here, so take it slow and read very carefully.

As the lock receives the soft top in it and locks, the small lever that is pushing on the switch releases just enough for the switch to click open once the lock itself is in closed position. If the lever has been bumped or bent when the front locks were installed, or if the locks have developed play over the years, then oftentimes the lever is not pushing down far enough by the time the lock is in the final (resting) locked position. This resting position can be different from the locked position without the top being latched down by the lock.

In your case, you probably have to bend that lever up just a tiny bit (1 mm or 1/32 inch). This adjustment can be made without removing the lock. Remove the windshield header panel and adjust the lever above the micro switch until it barely touches the switch when the lock is closed. Note the play in the lock - you need to recreate the position the lock would be in if the soft top was closed and pulling up on the lock. This is shown in the third photo with the caption "Front lock in real life with the top pulling". Ideally, the boot of the switch will just start bulging when the lock is in the "real life closed position".

Image


Image


Image


I hope this helps - please let us know what you find.

Klaus

Top Hydraulics | Rebuilt and Upgraded Convertible Top Cylinders, Pumps, Hydraulic Lines - Top Hydraulics, Inc
 
#12 ·
Adjusting "soft top closed switches"





Jeff,

Those shops with Star Diagnosis would eventually point at the front locks - less experienced shops might even suggest to get a new controller. Almost any shop would tell you to replace the front locks, because they don't know about the ultimately simple adjustment procedure below.

Fritha78 was referring to a thread that was just posted yesterday. The OP's problem was that the rear of the soft top wouldn't even close after a new soft top canvas was installed, and the root cause was the same.

The red light staying on and the chime going off once you start driving is a less severe version of the problem, and the chime only going off once you drive over a bump would be the version where the switches just start needing adjustment.

It is unusual that both micro switches need adjustment at the same time. Has any work been done to the front locks lately, where someone might have bumped the switches out of alignment, or did you replace the canvas or the weatherstripping above the windshield?

In any case, below is the procedure to adjust the front lock micro switches, mostly paraphrased from the thread that Fritha78 referenced:

Here is how to check which one of the front lock micro switches needs adjustment in your case, where the red light stays on after the top has closed all the way:

Put the soft top tool (6-mm Allen wrench) into the front lock on one side, through the hole in front of the visor. Turn the wrench such that it locks even farther, taking the play out of the lock. That direction is different on the opposite sides, by the way. It is counter-clockwise on the left side and clockwise on the right side. If the red light goes out, then you have found the lock that needs adjustment.

Try the same on the other side if necessary.

(You might get away with only adjusting the prongs on your soft top, following the instructions in http://www.benzworld.org/forums/r129...djustment.html, but that would likely be only a temporary fix and eventually result in the chime going off every time you drive over a bump.)

Adjustment procedure:

Note that you need to re-install the windshield header panel before the top will operate on model years '95+. Also, be careful not to pull on the wires of the magnetic sensor that is mounted in the windshield header panel on model years '95+. See page 3 of http://www.tophydraulicsinc.com/R129... Removal.pdf.

The micro switch on the front lock(s) gets pushed DOWN by a lever when the lock is OPEN. There is some reverse logic involved here, so take it slow and read very carefully.

As the lock receives the soft top in it and locks, the small lever that is pushing on the switch releases just enough for the switch to click open once the lock itself is in closed position. If the lever has been bumped or bent when the front locks were installed, or if the locks have developed play over the years, then oftentimes the lever is not pushing down far enough by the time the lock is in the final (resting) locked position. This resting position can be different from the locked position without the top being latched down by the lock.

In your case, you probably have to bend that lever up just a tiny bit (1 mm or 1/32 inch). This adjustment can be made without removing the lock. Remove the windshield header panel and adjust the lever above the micro switch until it barely touches the switch when the lock is closed. Note the play in the lock - you need to recreate the position the lock would be in if the soft top was closed and pulling up on the lock. This is shown in the third photo with the caption "Front lock in real life with the top pulling". Ideally, the boot of the switch will just start bulging when the lock is in the "real life closed position".

Image


Image


Image


I hope this helps - please let us know what you find.

Klaus

Top Hydraulics | Rebuilt and Upgraded Convertible Top Cylinders, Pumps, Hydraulic Lines - Top Hydraulics, Inc
 
#8 ·
Thanks for the info, you just saved me $1600 and only cost my 20 minutes of my time. I bent the drivers side lever just a fraction and now all is well.

This started a few weeks ago when I replaced my drivers side main and bow cylinders. I guess with the new cylinders the top was going into the lock a little differently and there was probably some play in the sensor mechanism due to age.

Klaus, thanks for the pictorial (and a belated thanks for the rebuilt cylinders).

-Jeff
 
#10 ·
You are now an official member of the "Top Hydraulics/Klaus Fan Club"!!!

Klaus ROCKS!

Daniel8888

If you are using a standard OBD-II reader, you won't get any error codes from the soft top system, as it is not part of OBD-II like engine and drive train systems are.

To read error codes from the soft top system you will need a Mercedes DAS diagnostic system.

Dan
 
#11 ·
Klaus, Thank You Very Much! The repair/replacement of the hydraulics on my 93 300 SL was as easy as you described in your literature. It took us three hours to remove all twelve cylinders and another three hours to reinstall. We did need to adjust one of the micro switches. Followed your diagnostic and adjustment procedure and the job was complete in just a couple of minutes. I would not have had the courage to tackle this job without your step by step instructions. As it is, I saved over $2500 from the estimate my local Mercedes specialist quoted. Again, Thanks! Vachel
 
#13 ·
Klaus's diagnosis and instructions were excellent! I had the same problem with my 1991 300 SL, beeping alarm when the soft top was all locked down. I read Klaus' post very thoroughly and studied his great clear pictures of the front locks and micro switches and diagnosis instruction and descriptions. I checked both top locks with the manual tool, and found that cranking the passenger side passenger side lock more fully did not turn the light out. I then checked the driver side and cranked with the manual tool and wow, that turned the red light off. Having isolated the faulty microswitch, (thanks to Klaus isolating the top switches and front locks as the likely culprits) I removed two phillips screws from the header lock covers, and removed both covers on each side. I was a little puzzled on how to get the header off the top at first, but after a while I took a deep breath, popped the header free by pulling up and sliding it backwards and exposed the locks and assemblies underneath. I located the microswitch and the lever, studied that for a while, thinking, I hope I don't totally break this thing off. I could see that it was pushing down fairly firmly on the micro switch. I slipped a screwdriver under the brass colored lever, and I then took a small pair of pliers on the end of the lever and slightly bent that lever up just a little bit. I could see that the lever was still pressing on the switch but with less pressure and the rubber underneath the switch bulged a little bit. I tested it by putting the soft top up automatically with the red panel switch. When the top was fully up the red light went out! No more alarm beeping.
Thank you Klaus, an excellent job diagnosing my problem and explaining it perfectly. You are worth your weight in gold! Cheers. Eddie, Eugene OR
 
#15 ·
I had the beep going on on my 91 500sl. The previous owner didn't drive it because of that. When I went to adjust the switches per the instructions I found on this forum, I discovered that the plunger was missing from the right side switch. It's a little microswitch with an integral mounting bracket which can not be had from MB. So I wired the right side switch to the left side switch and viola, no more beep! Now I just have to get all the cylinders rebuilt so I don't have to retract the soft top manually.